Why does the narrator reject the idea of selling and eating the twelve to fourteen-year-olds?

In A Modest Proposal, Swift suggests his scheme of selling Irish babies as food has 6 advantages, including reducing the number of Catholics, allowing the poor to pay rent, enriching the nation, relieving poor parents of the burden of raising children, improving the menu at taverns, and improving marriage and family

What is A Modest Proposal trying to solve?

Presented in the guise of an economic treatise, the essay proposes that the country ameliorate poverty in Ireland by butchering the children of the Irish poor and selling them as food to wealthy English landlords.

What objection does the speaker anticipate how does he answer this objection?

What objection does the speaker anticipate (lines 248-250)? How does he answer the objection? The objection that the speaker anticipates is that this would lessen Irelands population. He answers this objection by saying that this is the idea.

What is meant by the phrase a child just dropped from its dam?

What is meant by the phrase, a child just dropped from its dam? child is out of mother; new infant.

What are the six platforms of Swift’s argument?

What are the six principal advantages? According to the speaker, his plan would (1) reduce the number of Catholics, (2) give the poor a tangible asset, (3) aid the economy and introduce a new food, (4) decrease the time breeders have to raise children, (5) improve taverns business, and (6) encourage marriage.

What are some arguments that Swift uses for his modest proposal give examples?

An example of a logical argument used in his essay is I believe no Gentleman would repine to give Ten Shillings for the Carcass of a good fat Child, which, as I have said will make four Dishes of excellent Nutritive Meat (Smith, Paragraph 14). He argues the case for the Irish children to be used as food.

What is the author’s argument in A Modest Proposal?

The author argues, by hard-edged economic reasoning as well as from a self-righteous moral stance, for a way to turn this problem into its own solution. His proposal, in effect, is to fatten up these undernourished children and feed them to Irelands rich land-owners.

What is the opposing argument in A Modest Proposal?

The writer counterclaims by saying that the childrens skin would make good supplies such as gloves for the women and summer boots for the men. He also adds in the poor children are already dying for their poverty so might as well kill them off now with a great use of them.

What was the purpose of his solution in A Modest Proposal?

Swifts dark satirical solution is to eat the Irish babies, which would bring in profit and decrease the surplus population of Ireland.

What are the main solutions that Swift’s proposal would solve?

According to the speaker, his plan would (1) reduce the number of Catholics, (2) give the poor a tangible asset, (3) aid the economy and introduce a new food, (4) decrease the time breeders have to raise children, (5) improve taverns business, and (6) encourage marriage.

What is the real message of A Modest Proposal?

He wrote A Modest Proposal as an attempt to convince the Irish Parliament to improve the conditions of the poor. Swift used the idea of eating children as a metaphor for what he saw as the exploitation of the poor, such as the high rents charged by landlords.

What objection does swift anticipate and what is his response?

The author now anticipates an objection to his proposal–that it will too drastically reduce the national population. He admits this, reminding the reader that such a reduction was in fact one of the goals.

What is the one objection that the narrator thinks might possibly be raised against this proposal?

What is the one objection that the narrator thinks might possibly be raised against this proposal? It will reduce the number of people in the kingdom. It is morally repugnant.

Why does the Speaker reject the idea of selling and eating twelve to four teen year olds?

Why does the speaker reject the idea of selling and eating twelve to fourteen year olds? He rejects this because the males would have tough meat and would not have much meat, and the females could be breeders. About midway in the pamphlet, the speaker lists the advantages of his proposal.

What does the Speaker of A Modest Proposal think the food he proposes is very proper for landlords?

food or money for life support. Why does the speaker of A Modest Proposal think the food he proposes is very proper for landlords? The speaker says that the landlords should have the first claim on the flesh of the children since they have already figuratively devoured the parents.

What does DAM mean in modest proposal?

The word dam was used to refer to a human mother in contemptuous terms (by Shakespeare for example). However, I suspect in this case, it is because Swifts Modest Proposal is to rear and sell the children of the poor as food (for the privileged).

How does Swift’s use of the word dam?

Swift says that the problem facing the nation is the poor and starving people and children. The word dam (line 28) means female parent and is usually used to refer to a domestic animal

What does dressing them hot from the knife mean?

I rather recommend buying the children alive, and dressing them hot from the knife, as we do roasting pigs (A Modest Proposal). Comparing the children to roasting a pig shows that the children do not mean that much to anyone and they can just be burned alive and no one would care

What is Jonathan Swift’s main concern Why is he writing this proposal?

What is Jonathan Swifts main concern? Why is he writing this proposal? His main concern is the treatment of the Irish by the English, specifically the amount of children in poverty, and primarily what to do with them.

What are the 6 proposals in a modest proposal?

In A Modest Proposal, Swift suggests his scheme of selling Irish babies as food has 6 advantages, including reducing the number of Catholics, allowing the poor to pay rent, enriching the nation, relieving poor parents of the burden of raising children, improving the menu at taverns, and improving marriage and family

What are Swift’s six justifications for his proposal?

What are the six principal advantages? According to the speaker, his plan would (1) reduce the number of Catholics, (2) give the poor a tangible asset, (3) aid the economy and introduce a new food, (4) decrease the time breeders have to raise children, (5) improve taverns business, and (6) encourage marriage.

What is Swift’s argument?

Presented in the guise of an economic treatise, the essay proposes that the country ameliorate poverty in Ireland by butchering the children of the Irish poor and selling them as food to wealthy English landlords. Swifts proposal is a savage comment on Englands legal and economic exploitation of Ireland.

What is Swift’s economic argument?

A Modest Proposal made a rational economic argument to propose something unthinkable: have poor Irish familieswho mostly were Catholicsell their children to the rich to be eaten. Swift argued that: eating children would reduce the Catholic population

What evidence does Swift use in A Modest Proposal?

In A Modest Proposal, Swift suggests his scheme of selling Irish babies as food has 6 advantages, including reducing the number of Catholics, allowing the poor to pay rent, enriching the nation, relieving poor parents of the burden of raising children, improving the menu at taverns, and improving marriage and family

How does Swift justify his modest proposal?

What types of evidence does the speaker use to support his argument? Swift uses experts, statistics, logical thinking, and cost/benefit analysis to bolster his argument. What advantages does the speaker offer to the Irish people with his proposal? Name at least four.