In “The Fun They Had,” Asimov constructs a futuristic world in the year 2155, in which traditional school has been replaced with a computerized homeschooling system. The story follows an 11-year-old girl named Margie who is mystified by the “very old book” about school that her friend Tommy found. With young and curious Margie as the story’s protagonist, Asimov allows questions of technological progress to be filtered through a lens of innocence. Although treated with naiveté and frankness, Asimov’s story is a warning about the power of technological progress. In detailing this futuristic, computerized, and highly individualized educational system, the story suggests that technological progress can have major drawbacks, especially in the realm of education and social development: such a system is impersonal and minimizes human connection, which can be isolating and unproductive for students.
For Margie and Tommy, going to school means sitting alone in a room in their respective houses while staring at a television screen that mechanically transmits information at a computer-set pace—a system that is meant to be individualized and efficient. However, by contrasting human teachers with computers and artificial intelligence, Asimov suggests that such high-tech learning isn’t so efficient after all. In the story, students are taught individually by machines that can be adjusted by a human mechanic to meet each child’s specific learning needs. However, while the computers are individualized, they aren’t very personal; the robotic teachers lack human emotion and the ability to connect and support the student on a personal level. Instead, they’re just “big screen[s] on which all the lessons [are] shown and the questions [are] asked.” For instance, when Margie begins “doing worse and worse” in geography, the mechanical teacher can’t sit down with her and talk candidly about what she’s specifically struggling with or what other learning techniques might be helpful for her. Instead, it just gives her “test after test,” all of which she does poorly on. It gets so bad that Margie’s mother has to call the County Inspector, who is the mechanic that manually reprograms mechanical teachers and sets their pace for each individual student. Although Asimov constructs futuristic education as being based on artificial intelligence, it is paradoxical that a human must come and fix Margie’s computerized teacher. Because the technology itself—the mechanical computer—doesn’t have the ability to personalize itself to each student in the way that the human Inspector can, it seems that technological progress doesn’t necessarily lead to the more efficient and individualized education it strives to create.
However, when talking to Tommy about the kind of old-fashioned education that’s detailed in Tommy’s “very old book,” Margie expresses disbelief that a human could ever effectively teach students, saying bluntly, “A man can’t know as much as a [mechanical] teacher.” This is an important part of the point that Asimov is making: although it is true that a human being could never store and be able to recall as much raw data as a computer, a mechanical teacher lacks the ability to interact with students in the way that someone like the County Inspector can. With this, Asimov is providing an early but now familiar critique of the computer age: in exchange for a wealth of knowledge, society has traded more familiar and nourishing forms of human engagement.
The old book about school also pinpoints the lack human connection in computerized education when it comes to relationships among students. In contrasting the way students used to engage with one another versus the way they do in the story’s futuristic setting, Asimov emphasizes how technological progress can isolate humans from social interaction and replace fun and curiosity with efficiency and detachment. In the story, Margie’s interaction with other children is limited to occasionally playing with her friend Tommy. While discussing Tommy’s old book, Margie finds it difficult to believe that there could have been a time where children were taught in groups, because this contrasts so heavily with the individualized learning, she is familiar with. Asimov is suggesting here that although computers can present more information more quickly, such an approach perhaps deprives children of the important social experience of school. At the end of the story, Margie daydreams of the fun that her grandfather’s grandfather had when he was a boy, back when “all the kids from the whole neighborhood” flocked to the schoolyard every day, “laughing and shouting”—a situation that couldn’t be more different from the lonely way in which Margie learns. In this old-fashioned education, children “learned the same things, so they could help one another on the homework and talk about it.” Even though school in the old days is not individualized, students had the ability to learn from each other, which is another—perhaps richer—layer to education that Margie’s current system lacks.
On the surface, “The Fun They Had” is a simplistic, children’s story, yet Asimov also provides a serious warning that technological progress is not always social progress. The story clearly indicates the problems with computerized educational systems, including the lack of social interaction with other children, impersonal teachers and learning environments, and the inability for artificial intelligence to actively engage students in the learning process. Although the reader might imagine computerized learning to be more fun than traditional school, Asimov’s story critiques this notion by illustrating the downsides of such an approach.
Question 1: How old are Margie and Tommy?
Answer: Margie is 11 years old and Tommy is 13 years old.
Question 2: What did Margie write in her diary?
Answer: Margie wrote in her diary, “Today Tommy found a real book”.
Question 3: Had Margie ever seen a book before?
Answer: No, she had heard about a book from her grandfather.
Question 4: What things about the book did she find strange?
Answer: They found many strange things about the book. One of the strange things was that after reading the book became useless. Because the text written on it did not change the way it happened on their computer screen. Moreover, one page was having limited number of words, unlike computers where a page can display unlimited number of words.
Question 5: What do you think a telebook is?
Answer: A telebook can be an online book which can be browsed using internet. Or it can be displayed through TV signals on TV screen.
Question 6: Where was Margie’s school? Did she have any classmates?
Answer: Margie’s school was a virtual school in her house. She didn’t have classmates the way present day children have. At present children go to physical schools where they interact with real teachers and real classmates.
Question 7: What subjects did Margie and Tommy learn?
Answer: There is mention of subjects like Geography, Maths and History. But assuming a computer can be programmed to teach any subject they must be taught all relevant subjects.
Answer each of these questions in a short paragraph (about 30 words)Question 1: What kind of teachers did Margie and Tommy have?
Answer: Margie and Tommy have virtual teacher. It is computer fitted with latest gizmos. The computer is programmed to give lessons depending on a child’s age group and previous learning history. The content are highly interactive and children learn from the mechanical teacher. The child needs to submit test papers regularly to the computer and he gets instant feedback in the form of the test result.
Question 2: Why did Margie’s mother send for the County Inspector?
Answer: Margie was not performing up to the mark in her Geography tests. So her mother was worried. She wanted the County Inspector to check if there was some problem with the child or with the virtual teacher.
Question 3: What did he do?
Answer: He found that the computer’s programme was not working properly and was giving lessons, which was of higher level than what Margie’s age required. He rectified the problem and it started giving lessons suitable for Margie’s age group.
Question 4: What had once happened to Tommy’s teacher?
Answer: Tommy’s teacher developed some snag and its History section was blanked out. So it was taken away for a month for repair.
Question 5: Did Margie have regular days and hours for school? If so, why?
Answer: Margie did not have regular days and hours unlike conventional schools. The benefit of virtual classroom is it can be accessed as per your convenience. No more early morning rush for school. You can sleep as late as you wish and can compensate for your study during day time as you wish.
Question 6: How does Tommy describe the old kind of school?
Answer: Tommy said that centuries ago there used to be different kinds of school. There a human teacher used to give same lesson to all boys and girls of same age group. Students had to go to that school to study.
Question 7: How does he describe the old kind of teachers?
Answer: Old kind of teachers was human being. It is surprising how a human being can be smart enough to teach a particular topic.
Answer each of these questions in two or three paragraphs (100 –150 words)Question 1: What are the main features of the mechanical teachers and the schoolrooms that Margie and Tommy have in the story?
Answer: The mechanical teacher is a computer screen with good audio-video system. It taught students in mechanical voice and tone. It was always prompt in giving feedback after a child submitted his papers. It can store reams of information. Unlike a page in the real books, the mechanical teacher’s page is its screen. The screen can display unlimited number of words. The teacher is always present in their house and they can study as per their timings.
The teacher sometimes goes wrong as well. There can be some virus playing havoc with its programming. This may lead to inaccessibility of certain subjects. Sometimes this can lead the teacher to throw really difficult tests, which may not be fit for a particular child. Otherwise, the teacher is always programmed to suit each individual student’s learning need and capability.
Question 2. Why did Margie hate school? Why did she think the old kind of school must have been fun?
Answer: Her school was always open, seven days in a week. Margie’s teacher was always on at the same time except weekends, because her mother believed that regular study hours result in better learning.
She had no classmates to interact and play with. She thought that old school must have been fun, because, you got the opportunity to play and make fun, with your classmates. It must have been a pleasant experience to study from a human instead of impersonal machine.
Copyright © excellup 2014