Corneal reflection test (Hirschberg) (Hirschberg 1881) In the literature there is some confusion around the terms visual axis, pupillary axis, optical axis, line of sight, angle kappa and angle lambda. The visual axis is the line connecting the fovea and the nodal point of the eye and continuing anteriorly through the cornea. The pupillary axis is the line perpendicular to the cornea that intersects the centre of the pupil. It is a clinical approximation of the visual axis. The optical or anatomical axis of the eye connects the centre of the curvature of the cornea and the centre of the curvature of the posterior pole. The line of sight is the line that connects the fixation point and the centre of the pupil; it is a clinical approximation of the optical axis. The angle between visual and optical axis is called angle kappa. Landolt originally defined angle kappa as "the angle between the visual axis and the so‐called central pupillary line (the pupillary axis)" (Emsley 1948). Lancaster then defined angle lambda as the angle between the pupillary axis and the line of sight. LeGrand finally re‐defined angle kappa exactly the way Lancaster had defined angle lambda, stating that the nodal point of the eye is a theoretical concept, and that for all practical purposes the visual axis is identical to the line of sight (LeGrand 1980). In addition, angle lambda and angle kappa are nearly identical when the point of fixation is not very close to the eye. Angle kappa is the angle between the visual and optical axis, or between the pupillary axis and the line of sight (LeGrand 1980). By convention it is normally positive. Individuals with exotropia have higher angle kappa values than esotropic and orthotropic individuals (Basmak 2007). A large angle kappa may also give rise to pseudo‐exotropia. When the fovea is situated nasal to the optical axis, such as in high myopia or ectopic fovea, for example after retinopathy of prematurity, the angle kappa is negative, the CR is located temporal to the centre of the cornea, and pseudo‐esotropia may be present. In ocular misalignment, the CR is displaced – nasally in exotropia, temporally in esotropia (Hirschberg 1881). When the CR is located at the border of the pupil, the deviation is approximately 15 prism dioptres (PD). If it lies midway across the iris, the deviation measures around 30 PD, and when the reflection is near the limbus, around 45 PD. Hirschberg’s original observations indicated a ratio of 12 to 14 PDs per millimetre displacement of the CR from the pupillary axis, the so‐called Hirschberg ratio. Later evaluations of the Hirschberg test using photography to standardise measurements indicated a ratio of 19.5/1 (Wick 1980), 21/1 (Brodie 1987; DeRespinis 1989), 22/1 (Eskridge 1988) or 24/1 (Carter 1978) with little change from birth to adulthood (Hasebe 1998; Riddell 1994; Wick 1980). Photographs acquired whilst fixating with first the preferred eye, then the deviating eye, in primary position and in slightly eccentric fixation may allow a highly accurate measurement of the ocular misalignment (Romano 2006). Based mainly on reasons of photographic technique, some consider the limbus a more accurate landmark than the centre of the pupil (Barry 1997; Romano 2006); however displacement from the centre of the pupil remains the more commonly used value. Use of the Hirschberg test as a screening test for ocular alignment has been recommended in young preverbal and also in pre‐school children (daSilva 1991; Sansonetti 2004). To allow standardisation, videographic techniques have been proposed (Miller 1993). These can be applied when using video refractors or photoscreeners developed for the automated assessment of refractive errors (Griffin 1989; Hasebe 1995; Moghaddam 2012; Schaeffel 2002; Weinand 1998). Automated assessment of CR on digital photographs and videographs is currently in development (Almeida 2012; Model 2012; Yang, 2012). Accuracy of the Hirschberg test may be in the range of ± 9 to 10 PD, which would make it unsuitable to detect or exclude microtropia. In orthoptic practice, Hirschberg and Krimsky tests are reserved for very young, preverbal patients or those with profound visual impairment which prevents fixation with the affected eye(s). The Hirschberg test is useful to demonstrate pseudo‐strabismus in young children with a broad nasal bridge and epicanthal folds or in individuals with wide interpupillary distance. Coaxial fundus reflex test (Brückner) The Brückner test (Brückner 1965; Tongue 1981) is based on reflection of light by the fundus/retina at the back of the eye. A bright coaxial light source and observation system is used, usually a direct ophthalmoscope. Both eyes of the patient are simultaneously illuminated from a distance of around one metre. The observer notes any difference in brightness of the fundus reflex seen in the pupil through the ophthalmoscope. In the presence of strabismus the reflex is darker in the fixing eye than in the deviated eye. An additional, dynamic examination of pupil size, pupil reaction to light, and fixation movement of the eyes on alternating illumination can be useful to detect amblyopia (Tongue 1981). Whilst the manual Brückner test appears reliable at detecting strabismus, it may give rise to false positives, and its usefulness in screening for ocular misalignment is unclear (Griffin 1986; Griffin 1989). A recent evaluation of a modified Brückner test, performed using a streak retinoscope, indicated a sensitivity of 0.5, specificity of 0.98, negative predictive value of 0.97 and positive likelihood ratio of 20 to detect strabismus in a cohort of 343 children with a 5% prevalence of strabismus (Amitava 2012). Photographic and videographic versions of the Brückner test may also have high sensitivity and specificity to detect strabismus (Carrera 1993; Cibis 1994; Kaakinen 1979; Miller 1995; VanEenwyk 2008). Some photorefractors use the Brückner principle, as refractive errors cause a white crescent at the pupil border (Arnold 2000; Kothari 2007; Tongue 1987; Weinand 1998). These devices are commonly used in community screening programmes, operated by lay observers (Arnold 2000). Sensitivity and specificity appear higher on analysis of the coaxial fundus reflex on photographs than during manual performance of the test (Paysse 2001). The size of misalignment may affect the accuracy of the Brückner test, with lower sensitivity in small‐angle esotropia (Graf 2012). Stereovision tests Tests of stereovision may indicate ocular misalignment. As other causes — such as uncorrected refractive errors and reduced visual acuity — also impair stereopsis, specificity for any particular cause may be poor. Stereopsis is most commonly tested at near. Near stereotests fall into two categories: contour (Titmus fly, Wirt ring test); and random dot tests. Contour tests achieve horizontal image disparity by vectographic techniques and require polarised glasses to view a three‐dimensional (3D) picture embedded in polarised filter sheets made from plastic. By stacking two of these sheets at a perpendicular angle, a separate image is shown to each eye. When viewed without the glasses, the picture can still be seen, but its 3D qualities can only be perceived through the polarising glasses. As contour tests gives some monocular cues to the position of the 3D shapes many clinicians prefer random dot tests for testing stereovision. Random dot images do not contain any contour lines. Shapes can only be seen and depth can only be perceived when true binocular stereopsis with central (foveal) fusion is present. Random dot tests include the Frisby, Lang, TNO, Randot and Randot‐E stereotests (Broadbent 1990; Lang 1983; Rosner 1984; Simons 1981b). The Frisby test consists of three Perspex plates of different thickness. On each plate there are four square areas which contain triangular shapes apparently distributed in a random pattern. On one of the squares, some shapes arranged in a geometric pattern, such as a circle, are printed onto the back surface of the Perspex plate, whilst the remaining square is filled with triangles printed onto the front surface. The physical thickness of the Perspex plate and the distance between the shapes printed onto the front and the back of the plate induce horizontal image disparity. This test is simple to perform, does not require 3D viewers and is popular with children. Preverbal children may point onto the 3D shape or may direct their eyes towards it, similar to their response in preferential looking tests. The Lang stereotest combines two methods of three‐dimensional image perception: random dots and cylindrical gratings. The cylindrical gratings use a prismatic effect to achieve the slight horizontal image displacement required for a 3D effect. The advantage of this method is that it does not require special glasses for viewing. Essentially, the separation of the two images is achieved by a system of fine parallel cylindrical shapes. Beneath each cylinder are two fine strips of picture, one seen by the right, the other seen by the left eye. In the Lang test, random dot images hide simple shapes such as a star, a cat, a car. As it does not require 3D viewers, it is easy to use with children and is commonly used in vision screening programmes. Like the Frisby test, it can be used in preverbal children by observing their behavioural response. The Randot and Random dot E stereotests require polarising glasses for viewing. Images of animals and geometric shapes are horizontally displaced using vectographic techniques. These tests allow fine grading of stereopsis, but not all children will like wearing the polarising glasses. The TNO test creates a 3D effect by using red‒green anaglyphs. Red‒green anaglyphs are based on two images showing the same scene from a slightly different angle. One image is processed through a red, and the other image through a green or blue or mixed (cyan) filter. The resulting images are superimposed, but slightly offset. When viewing these pictures through glasses with one red and one green lens, a stereoscopic effect results. Near stereotests are not sufficiently accurate to be used as standalone vision screening tests (Donahue 2013; Huynh 2005; Ohlsson 2002; Schmidt 2003; VIP 2005; VIP 2007). Testability is affected by age (Pai 2012; Schmidt 2003). Distance stereopsis can be measured with the distance Frisby stereotest, a cabinet which houses Perspex plates which present random images at slightly different distances from the observer (Adams 2005; Holmes 2005; Kaye 2005), or with a distance Randot test (Fu 2006). Despite reports of high sensitivity to detect vision defects (Rutstein 2000), distance stereopsis has not been evaluated in vision screening programmes. Distance stereoacuity can be reduced in convergence excess esotropia and intermittent distance exotropia (Hatt 2008). Visual acuity tests In older children and adults, VA is assessed by reading a chart of characters, or optotypes, at a defined distance. In very young children, assessment of visual acuity relies on observation of behavioural responses to visual targets. Preferential looking cards showing patterns of high‐contrast black and white stripes are used in children under the age of 2 years to determine “grating acuity” (Dobson 1978). In strabismic amblyopia, grating acuity is reduced to a lesser degree than linear letter acuity and results may overestimate the level of vision. From the age of 2 years, single symbols such as Kay pictures can be used (Kay 1983). From the age of 3 years, crowded linear optotypes such as HOTV, or crowded Kay or Lea pictures can be used. These tests are often used in childhood vision screening programmes (Schmidt 2004; Hered 1997; Anonymous 2004). Crowded optotypes (several characters next to each other) viewed one eye at a time (monocularly), such as on HOTV or logMAR charts, are considered the 'gold standard' for visual acuity testing (Schmidt 2004). The use of crowded optotypes instead of single optotypes is particularly important in amblyopia screening, as single optotype testing can overestimate visual acuity. All visual acuity tests can be performed either by the child calling out the name of the picture or letter, or by the child matching the target optotype with a chart held by a parent/guardian. More detailed letter‒optotype tests include the Keeler logMar and the Sonksen Silver logMar tests. In order to both increase portability of charts and reduce variation of illumination levels, computer‐based testing applications are available and used in some screening settings (Thomson 1999). Visual acuity tests can be administered by any suitably trained person. In the UK, screening programmes are delivered by qualified orthoptists, health care technicians or school nurses trained by orthoptists (Hall 2003; UK National Screening Committee) In the USA, paediatric vision screening is usually performed by suitably trained nurses or lay screeners. Autorefractors/Photorefractors
Photorefraction analyses the reflection of light emitted from a small flashlight placed close to the camera lens. Three types of photorefraction have been developed: orthogonal, isotropic and eccentric (also called photoretinoscopy). Refractive errors result in certain patterns of photographic appearances, which vary with the degree to which the eye is defocused with respect to the plane of the camera (Howland 1974; Howland 2009). Photorefractors are mainly used to obtain refractive values. Some devices combine a photographic Brückner test and eccentric photorefraction to detect amblyogenic risk factors (Cibis 1994; VanEenwyk 2008). Several current photorefractors also detect strabismus as asymmetry of corneal light reflections (Arnold 2013; Dahlmann‐Noor 2009a; Dahlmann‐Noor 2009b; Moghaddam 2012; Silbert 2013). The following table summarises possible test outcomes, pass/fail thresholds and examples of published screening studies that have used these tests. The variation of tests used in different studies for each group of index tests means that many specific tests have only been used in one or a small number of studies.
Other tests used in the diagnosis of strabismus, but not in primary care or community screening settings delivered by lay screeners or primary care professionals Krimsky test
Prism reflection test
Controlled binocular acuity (CBA) test of strabismus Suppression tests Fusion tests
Blur test
#1 MeSH descriptor: [Vision Tests] explode all trees #2 MeSH descriptor: [Mass Screening] explode all trees #3 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 (vision or visual*) #4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 program* #5 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 (communit* or population) #6 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 hospital* #7 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 (nursery or preschool* or school*) #8 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 (referred or referal or monit*) #9 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) near/4 (orthoptist* or ophthalmologist* or optometrist*) #10 #1 or #2 or #3 or #4 or #5 or #6 or #7 or #8 or #9 #11 MeSH descriptor: [Strabismus] explode all trees #12 strabism* or squint* #13 esotrop* or exotrop* #14 hypertrop* or hypotrop* #15 microtrop* #16 MeSH descriptor: [Amblyopia] this term only #17 amblyop* #18 lazy near/3 eye* #19 #11 or #12 or #13 or #14 or #15 or #16 or #17 or #18 #20 MeSH descriptor: [Infant] this term only #21 MeSH descriptor: [Child, Preschool] this term only #22 MeSH descriptor: [Child] this term only #23 infan* or child* or toddler* or boy* or girl* or paediatric* or pediatric* or nursery or nurseries or kindergarten* or pre school* or preschool* or school age or schoolage* #24 #20 or #21 or #22 or #23 #25 MeSH descriptor: [Photogrammetry] this term only #26 MeSH descriptor: [Photography] this term only #27 MeSH descriptor: [Blinking] this term only #28 corneal light reflection* #29 corneal reflection* #30 CLRT #31 (cover or uncover) near/3 test* #32 fundus reflection* #33 (Hirschberg* or Krimsky* or Bruckner*) near/5 test* #34 MeSH descriptor: [Retinoscopy] this term only #35 retinoscop* #36 stereoscopy or stereotest* #37 Randot #38 random dot #39 two pencil test #40 Frisby* or Titmus* #41 TNO or FD2 #42 HOTV or LEA #43 suppression near/3 test* #44 autorefractor* or photorefractor* or Plusoptix or Retinomax #45 #25 or #26 or #27 or #28 or #29 or #30 or #31 or #32 or #33 or #34 or #35 or #36 or #37 or #38 or #39 or #40 or #41 or #42 or #43 or #44 #46#10 and #19 and #24 and #45 1. exp vision tests/ 2. exp mass screening/ 3. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (vision or visual$)).tw. 4. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 program$).tw. 5. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (communit$ or population)).tw. 6. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 hospital$).tw. 7. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (nursery or preschool$ or school$)).tw. 8. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (referred or referral or monit$)).tw. 9. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (orthoptist$ or ophthalmologist$ or optometrist$)).tw. 10. or/1‐9 11. exp strabismus/ 12. (strabism$ or squint$).tw. 13. (esotrop$ or exotrop$).tw. 14. (hypertrop$ or hypotrop$).tw. 15. microtrop$.tw. 16. amblyopia/ 17. amblyop$.tw. 18. (lazy adj3 eye$).tw. 19. or/11‐18 20. Infant/ 21. child, preschool/ 22. child/ 23. (infan$ or child$ or toddler$ or boy$ or girl$ or paediatric$ or paediatric$ or nursery or nurseries or kindergarten$ or pre school$ or preschool$ or schoolage$ or school age$).tw. 24. or/20‐23 25. Photogrammetry/ 26. Photography/ 27. Blinking/ 28. corneal light reflection$.tw. 29. corneal reflection$.tw. 30. CLRT.tw. 31. ((cover or uncover) adj3 test$).tw. 32. fundus reflection$.tw. 33. ((Hirschberg$ or Krimsky$ or Bruckner$) adj5 test$).tw. 34. Retinoscopy/ 35. retinoscop$.tw. 36. (stereoscopy or stereotest$).tw. 37. Randot.tw. 38. random dot.tw. 39. two pencil test.tw. 40. (Frisby$ or Titmus$).tw. 41. (TNO or FD2).tw. 42. (HOTV or LEA).tw. 43. (suppression adj3 test$).tw. 44. (autorefractor$ or photorefractor$ or Plusoptix or Retinomax).tw. 45. or/25‐44 46. 10 and 19 and 24 and 45 1. exp vision test/ 2. exp mass screening/ 3. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (vision or visual$)).tw. 4. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 program$).tw. 5. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (communit$ or population)).tw. 6. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 hospital$).tw. 7. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (nursery or preschool$ or school$)).tw. 8. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (referred or referral or monit$)).tw. 9. ((test$ or screen$ or diagnos$ or assess$) adj4 (orthoptist$ or ophthalmologist$ or optometrist$)).tw. 10. or/1‐9 11. exp strabismus/ 12. (strabism$ or squint$).tw. 13. (esotrop$ or exotrop$).tw. 14. (hypertrop$ or hypotrop$).tw. 15. microtrop$.tw. 16. amblyopia/ 17. amblyop$.tw. 18. (lazy adj3 eye$).tw. 19. or/11‐18 20. Infant/ 21. preschool child/ 22. child/ 23. (infan$ or child$ or toddler$ or boy$ or girl$ or paediatric$ or pediatric$ or nursery or nurseries or kindergarten$ or pre school$ or preschool$ or schoolage$ or school age$).tw. 24. or/20‐23 25. Eye photography/ 26. Medical photography/ 27. Photography/ 28. Blinking/ 29. Hirschberg cornea light reflection test/ 30. corneal light reflection$.tw. 31. corneal reflection$.tw. 32. CLRT.tw. 33. ((cover or uncover) adj3 test$).tw. 34. fundus reflection$.tw. 35. ((Hirschberg$ or Krimsky$ or Bruckner$) adj5 test$).tw. 36. Retinoscopy/ 37. retinoscop$.tw. 38. (stereoscopy or stereotest$).tw. 39. Randot.tw. 40. random dot.tw. 41. two pencil test.tw. 42. Frisby test/ 43. Revised Frisby Davis Distance test/ 44. (Frisby$ or Titmus$).tw. 45. TNO stereotest/ 46. (TNO or FD2).tw. 47. (HOTV or LEA).tw. 48. (suppression adj3 test$).tw. 49. (autorefractor$ or photorefractor$ or Plusoptix or Retinomax).tw. 50. or/25‐49 51. 10 and 19 and 24 and 50 S34 S28 and S33 S33 S29 or S30 or S31 or S32 S32 infan* or child* or toddler* or boy* or girl* or paediatric* or pediatric* or nursery or nurseries or kindergarten* or pre school* or preschool* or schoolage* or school age* S31 (MH "Child+") S30 (MM "Child, Preschool") S29 (MH "Infant+") S28 S18 and S27 S27 S19 or S20 or S21 or S22 or S23 or S24 or S25 or S26 S26 lazy N3 eye S25 amblyop* S24 (MM "Amblyopia") S23 microtrop* S22 hypertrop* or hypotrop* S21 esotrop* or exotrop* S20 strabism* or squint* S19 (MM "Strabismus") S18 S1 or S2 or S3 or S4 or S5 or S6 or S7 or S8 or S9 or S10 or S11 or S12 or S13 or S14 or S15 or S16 or S17 S17 optometrist* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S16 ophthalmologist* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S15 orthoptist* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S14 monit* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S13 referral N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S12 referred N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S11 school* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S10 preschool* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S9 nursery N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S8 hospital* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S7 population N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S6 communit* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S5 program* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S4 visual* N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S3 vision N4 (test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) S2 (MM "Vision Screening") S1 (MH "Vision Tests+") #20 #15 AND #18 AND #19 #19 TS= (infan* or child* or toddler* or boy* or girl* or paediatric* or pediatric* or nursery or nurseries or kindergarten* or pre school* or preschool* or schoolage* or school age*) #18 #16 OR #17 #17 TS= (esotrop* or exotrop* or hypertrop* or hypotrop* or microtrop*) #16 TS= (strabimus or strabismic or squint*) #15 #1 OR #2 OR #3 OR #4 OR #5 OR #6 OR #7 OR #8 OR #9 OR #10 OR #11 OR #12 OR #13 OR #14 #14 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 optometrist*) #13 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 ophthalmologist*) #12 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 orthoptist*) #11 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 monitor*) #10 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 referral*) #9 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 referred*) #8 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 hospital*) #7 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 population*) #6 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 communit*) #5 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 program*) #4 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 visual*) #3 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 vision) #2 TS=mass screening #1 TS= vision test #20 #15 AND #18 AND #19 #19 TS= (infan* or child* or toddler* or boy* or girl* or paediatric* or pediatric* or nursery or nurseries or kindergarten* or pre school* or preschool* or schoolage* or school age*) #18 #16 OR #17 #17 TS= (esotrop* or exotrop* or hypertrop* or hypotrop* or microtrop*) #16 TS= (strabimus or strabismic or squint*) #15 #1 OR #2 OR #3 OR #4 OR #5 OR #6 OR #7 OR #8 OR #9 OR #10 OR #11 OR #12 OR #13 OR #14 #14 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 optometrist*) #13 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 ophthalmologist*) #12 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 orthoptist*) #11 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 monitor*) #10 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 referral*) #9 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 referred*) #8 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 hospital*) #7 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 population*) #6 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 communit*) #5 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 program*) #4 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 visual*) #3 TS= ((test* or screen* or diagnos* or assess*) NEAR/4 vision) #2 TS=mass screening #1 TS= vision test Database was searched on ICPC code field. Using code "f" for ophthalmology. (strabismus OR amblyopia) AND (test OR screen OR diagnosis OR assess) (strabismus OR amblyopia) AND (test OR screen OR diagnosis OR assess) strabismus OR amblyopia = Condition AND test OR screen OR diagnosis OR assess = Intervention Page 2
|